I very much like the idea of cleaning up THR L&P, but now I am confused. I believe the real need was to raise the level of civility...get back on the High Road. The part about what is an appropriate topic, i.e. one that would be passed by the mods, I suspect remains very arbitrary or will be defended as gun related by the thinnest of rationales. Economics for example is a favored topic. To say that it is gun related is pretty abstract. Some connection could be rationalized for anything that was favored.
As long as it is entirely civil, juvenile pejoratives and vitriol omitted, the actual connection to guns is not critical. Allowing the full range of civil liberties covers a lot of territory. I would rather be either strict or lenient, not arbitrary, never knowing what will pass and what won't. The THR charter has not been literally upheld before, so I am just wondering if anything has really changed.
If the intent was to finally declare that THR would be about guns, period, that is not yet clear to me.
It was also confusing to have on-topic threads closed because they were infested with poor behavior. I would hope that some of the same issues can be covered while having material believed substandard deleted.