This case doesn't much look like it has much to do with abortion.
Hopefully, Kavanaugh will rule correctly when it counts.
Indeed, it doesn't.
Basically, Planned Parenthood went and jumped through all the hoops to become a Medicaid provider.* Due to the hoopla about baby fetuses, which hasn't been criminally investigated, much less charged, a number of states attempted to deny PP medicaid payments for services it provides. Without a
conviction, this amounts to ex post facto law, which is specifically banned in the constitution, and not even in the bill of rights.
Basically, it's about the states/feds paying their bills when they're supposed to by color of law. Zero about abortion if you're a constitutionalist. And if you're a constitutionalist you shouldn't be making decisions about constitutional matters solely in order to hit a single company, PP or not. Because remember, you're
setting precedent. If made to slam PP, suddenly states could start denying payment to businesses willy-nilly.
Perhaps ironically, because PP is often the lowest cost/most available source** of birth control for people, denied funding the unintended pregnancy rate would likely rise and increase the number of abortions. Not to mention the number of children in "the system", taking up gobs of additional money. I remember that coming up when Texas defunded some program "to save money" and the auditors came back with "Yeah, about that, it's going to start costing us an extra $300M/year within 3 years".
Not to mention the extra expenses due to delayed treatment for various other conditions, prenatal care, etc...
*Note: Medicaid doesn't pay for abortions short of life of the mother. Not even
health is technically enough. Your pregnancy going to make you a diabetic or cost you a leg? Sorry, pay for your abortion yourself. I'm not a professional, this is just what I read. I'm pretty sure that "most" doctors would allow that diabetes/losing a limb is traumatic enough to be at significant risk for death, but...
**I know condoms are cheap, but free is hard to beat, and having a backup for this stuff isn't bad.