Here's my concern with reciprocity. Without clear legislation explaining what is and is not legal, there will be problems. Here in Ohio, I can carry a Glock 17 fully loaded with a +2 adapter for 20 rounds in the gun, loaded up with whatever hollow points I got the best deal on at the store. Now, let's say an EO or federal law gets passed that simply says my permit is good in all 50 states plus DC, so I now carry to visit family in New York, and plan a stop to see a college buddy in Jersey. Can I still carry the Glock 17 in New York with the 19 round mags, or with their SAFE act restrict me to 10 round mags? Do I need to load up ball ammo to legally carry in Jersey?
Honestly, if reciprocity does get passed, my Smith revolver will be my travel gun until all of this gets sorted out, as I don't want to be the guy arrested for illegal possession of high cap mags, etc. and end up sitting in jail somewhere while it all gets argued in court.