I'm all for the idea of CREATING a community that requires gun ownership (Citadel project, for example)
Not so hot on making gun ownership mandatory if people already live there who don't want to.
If given the CHOICE between forcing gun ownership or forcing no guns, I'd prefer the first, but neither is preferable.
Freedom is freedom. Just as no one has a right to tell me I can't have a firearm, I have no right to tell someone else they must.