I can't help it, I have to take issue with a couple of these.
First of all, if the bartender is conventionally/sorority-girl hot, then yeah, it's not a dive. On the other hand, if her hair is some color not found in nature, she has lots of visible tattoos, more metal in her flesh than you have in your pockets, and she's
still hot, then you may well be in a dive.
Second, what do you call a 'good' jukebox? I like Merle Haggard. So if the place has Merle, Willie, Waylon, Hank,
and Van Halen, then you could be in a dive. In my opinion, any beer joint gets extra points for a jukebox that leans heavily toward musicians who died prematurely.
- If the bartender is a woman and she's hot, it's definitely NOT a dive.
...
- If the place has a good jukebox, it's not a dive.
- If the place has a jukebox stuck on Merle Haggard, it might be a dive.
To carry CRT360's point a little further... If it's called the Stumble Inn, Drift Inn, or Dew Drop Inn, then it's probably a dive. In fact, any place which has a name that includes the word 'Inn' could be a dive. Likewise names like 'Da Spot' or 'The Office' are probably dives.
Finally, if it can legitimately be called a 'beer joint', it might be a dive.
James