They aren't married in or by the Catholic Church. And we are all sinners, gay or not. We just aren't supposed to celebrate sin.
God loves everyone. He hates sin though. If God created us differently so that it were not totally illogical and had Jesus blessed homosexuality, I would not be personally opposed to it, but if other religions still condemned it, I would oppose it on exactly the same grounds that this is a thinly veiled attack on religious liberty.
And if your aunt had ____, she'd be your uncle. This is a cheap cop out. You admit the state of the world and then say that you don't want the necessary results of your position because... well... that's not what you want.
You're still going to push for your position despite the fact that it will restrict religious liberty, but say that it makes you feel bad that it does. How nice.
First, thanks for the real answers. Would you be so kind as to answer the first question?
Regarding this, "but if other religions still condemned it, I would oppose it on exactly the same grounds that this is a thinly veiled attack on religious liberty," are there things that other religions condemn that you don't support? To clarify, I doubt you support what every religion says and you make actually support opposing views.
My point in #3 was just to say that no matter what happens with gay marriage, the people in this country are becoming less independant and liberty-minded whle becoming more dependant on government. That creates the situation where those people (dependents, leftists, etc) actively try to force people into their way of thinking. I don't want to force you, or anyone else, to accept gay marriage. I want to remove the barriers that tell people what they can not do, from the government's perspective. I still support and encourage you, your church, any business, and everyone else to decide with whom they associate. Under no circumstance do I want to require you to accept gays, gay marriage, or anything else you don't like.
As an aside, are there federal laws that prohibit gay marriage?