Update:
Bought the DVD for the kiddos a couple weeks back, since they enjoy the movie (ages 4 & 5).
Catching bits here & there over time, I have come to the conclusion that COL Scarhead is my favorite character in the abominable movie.
Here's why:
1. He gives the Jake character a real mission in Jake's directionless life and promises to square him away in return.
2. He is honest throughout the movie to all.
3. He does his job to the best of his ability.
4. He demonstrates remarkable fortitude and physical courage.
5. Highly motivated.
6. Holds up his end of the deal. He has everything set up for the Jake character to go back and get fixed up.
Here is where COL Scarhead screws up, IMO:
1. Doesn't recognize Jake has flipped sides. He ought to have noticed that and not given Jake a choice to get on the ship, head home, and get fixed up, just made it happen , even if he had to throw Jake over his shoulder like a sack of taters.
2. Didn't read his history WRT battles between civilized folks & multitudinous savages. I can forgive this, in that the movie plot & climax dictate he blunders.