The last 4-8 years of those messages being beaten to death is what lead to a Republican loss. If those really were how the majority of republican voters felt, than Tancredo, Fred Thompson or Brownbeck would have been the Republican candidates.
Two of those three ideas can be easily tied to GWB and the last one loosely.
Beaten to death?
GWB pushed zero pro-life initiatives and gave only infrequent lip-service. He was
in favor of mass immigration & amnesty. His position on gay marriage is that taken by
every presidential candidate & vice presidential candidate from the Republicans & Democrats since the issue came about, to include BHO.
And my claims for the issues' popularity was not WRT Republicans, but the
general population.Also, you might have noticed that:
1. The conservative vote in the Republican primaries was split several ways.
2. While these issues are popular, they are not the
only issues. Three issues does not a coalition make. Add things that may not be dear to fundies, but are dear to other coalition partners (fiscal conservatism, strong defense, law & oerder, etc.) and you start to have a coalition.
Until Nixon activated the evangelicals, Republicans had been a minority party for 40 years. Their addition to the Republican coalition made the Republicans a majority party, able to compete nationally. Toss them over the side and you can expect another 40 years in the wilderness.
Sorry, your analysis does not stand up to reality.