And guitars are kinda like guns: they breed in the dark (or, for me, instruments in general)...
This time last year, I had my old BC Rich Gunslinger, an inexpensive violin, and a lap harp in SERIOUS need of rebuilding.. Today, looking around my office, there's a Gibson Les Paul II, two Steinbergers (bass and six string), a Kramer/Ferrington acoustic, the gunslinger, parts for a BC Rich Warlock project, an "A" style mandolin, the harp, and a bouzouki on the way. All get played at some point in any given week (except the harp: it STILL needs rebuilding)...
Go to the store, play everything that looks interesting. Go with what feels best. Don't bother plugging in: you can change the sound via electronics swap anytime...