Executive experience - neither has a whole lot, so maybe a tie.
Tied at 0 on that one.
Foreign policy - serious edge to McCain. BHO clearly has no clue how the world really works.
McCain speaks as though the Soviet Union and Czechoslovikia still exist. He's referenced them by name recently. Dude might be slightly out of touch with the real world. I can't be real confident in a guy that's 10 years behind the whole "what countries actually exist" issue.
Taxes - McCain wants to not raise taxes, BHO wants to raise them. Edge to McCain, but personally I think big tax cuts are in order.
I ran across a utility that would calculate your taxes under both plans recently. Obama was definitely in my favor on that one. That surprised me given that I was using a figure of about $120k for a married couple.
Spending - McCain wants to hold the line. BHO has a whole litany of things he wants to spend more on....
Point to McCain there.
Defense - BHO totally clueless on this, too. Big edge to McCain.
*yawn* Bring every American soldier home and then we'll talk about defense. Neither candidate it speaking my language on that topic.