Armed Polite Society
Main Forums => The Roundtable => Topic started by: vaskidmark on October 29, 2013, 08:52:26 PM
-
I was talked into watching a network television show - the first time I have done so in years.
Hory clap, Batman! The background music is louder than the dialog! If there was dialog. All I got was snippets of words when the music paused for a second or two.
So, is this merely an oulde pharte problem caused by hair growing out of my ears and generally losing the ability to hear certain tones? Or have the networks (ABC in this case, Agents of Shield* to be particular) never bothered to listen to their productions?
stay safe.
* - I refuse to acronymize it and put periods in between all the letters.
-
Dunno. I haven't watched significant amounts of notwork TeeVee since Babylon 5 came to its finale.
-
I think it's an old fart problem. My wife and I have no problem hearing the dialog on that show.
-
Agree that many shows have background music and effects that swamp the dialog - in fact, about a year or two back, the local rag's TV critic mentioned in his column that this was the single most frequent complaint he sees from TV viewers. In fact, some hardware manufacturers are adding sound modes like "Clear Voice" to their TVs to try and deal with this issue.
And it's not just TV - programs, it exists on DVD and Blu0Ray movies, too; some players have a setting that boosts the center channel (which contains most dialog) by 3dB in an effort to make speech intelligible.
Sometimes it's so bad on certain programs I have to bypass the TV speakers and put the sound through my home theater system - that does a better job of separating out the dialog than the pseudo-surround from the TV's own stereo speakers.
-
I'm losing my hearing so I know what you are going through.
-
Is this just an oulde pharte problem?
Yes. And I'm on your lawn, too. :P
-
I have a hard time with it as well. I tend to watch TV and movies with captions on even when I can hear the dialog just to make sure I don't miss anything.
Chris
-
I was just watching Ronin and having a real hard time understanding the dialog. I rationalized that movie soundtracks are super dynamic, I dont have a proper center speaker, and I need bigger speakers. I'm not even 30 yet so it can't be my hearing.
Seriously though, I wish they mastered DVDs with a "nighttime mode" compressed soundtrack.
-
I have the same problem. Not so much since I got a Samsung sound bar with the dedicated center "voice" speaker. Even then, it has several modes, and if I put it on movie mode, I still have the problem. I end up listening to a lot of stuff in "news" mode, or else I put on my wireless headphones, which seem to alleviate the problem to a great degree, but can get uncomfortable towards the end of a long movie.
-
I haven't noticed this problem, and I tend to watch that stuff on old TV sets and mediocre PC components. I don't have especially good hearing, either.
-
No problem here. I sold my last tv on a yard sale 18 years ago when we moved out to the farm.
What little exposure I've had to network teevee since seemed the parts I could hear were a crappy waste of time and energy and the parts I couldn't hear were worse.
-
zahc:
Seriously though, I wish they mastered DVDs with a "nighttime mode" compressed soundtrack.
Me too, great idea. I was toying with the idea of experimenting with putting clipper diodes on the inputs of my external powered computer speakers. Another problem is the widely-varying volume when switching from one you-tube video to another. Example: I like to watch vids of engine startups. I set the volume for one and the next one blows my ears off.
Terry, 230RN
-
has anyone tried using a good EQ?
-
Huh? what'd you say?
I've got a bit of high frequency loss. Not sure how extensive it is but a few years ago wife was watching some documentary where they were showing hearing tests. When they got to the high freq sounds I couldn't hear it. My daughter in the next room could.
I also can't hear the alarm on my Casio G-shock unless it's right next to my ear.
-
I wonder if its a problem of speaker settings (whether the mixing settings in the original material or in the user's equipment).
Maybe the audio channels for the broadcast / cablecast is mixed for a modern 5.1 system?
Maybe the audio settings on the TV are set for 5.1 system that isn't hooked up?
I notice on my Netflix streams that Netflix defaults to 5.1 audio, even though I only have built in TV speakers. Switching it to std stereo makes the audio much cleaner. I've seen this many time with my setup that mismatched settings or incoming signal will wash out the dialog and cause the music and background effects to overwhelm it.
-
I end up listening to a lot of stuff in "news" mode, or else I put on my wireless headphones, which seem to alleviate the problem to a great degree, but can get uncomfortable towards the end of a long movie.
What brand do you use and what kind of price are you talking about? I been thinking about a set for watching the tube after the wife goes to bed. How's the quality, etc?
-
What brand do you use and what kind of price are you talking about? I been thinking about a set for watching the tube after the wife goes to bed. How's the quality, etc?
I started out with some expensive Sennheisers, which, while they produced really great sound, also delivered static, apparently from other wireless devices (I live in a condo complex), even though I would continually cycle through wireless channels. There were a couple of places in the house that I could sit without getting interference, but it was unacceptable to me. That doesn't mean I wouldn't recommend them to someone in a different environment, less prone to interference - they are a great headphone.
I'm currently using the Sony MDR-RF985RK. They also deliver great sound, but I don't get any interference with them.
I really like headphone sound, because I seem to be able to pick up everything in the sound range of whatever I'm watching much more clearly than over the speakers, especially voices. The only downside for me, as I mentioned above, is they can get a little tiresome to wear for longer periods. A two hour movie isn't bad at all though. There might be some acceptable ultra lightweight headphones out there, I just didn't find any that would plug into my TV's optical.
-
I started out with some expensive Sennheisers, which, while they produced really great sound, also delivered static, apparently from other wireless devices (I live in a condo complex), even though I would continually cycle through wireless channels. There were a couple of places in the house that I could sit without getting interference, but it was unacceptable to me. That doesn't mean I wouldn't recommend them to someone in a different environment, less prone to interference - they are a great headphone.
I'm currently using the Sony MDR-RF985RK. They also deliver great sound, but I don't get any interference with them.
I really like headphone sound, because I seem to be able to pick up everything in the sound range of whatever I'm watching much more clearly than over the speakers, especially voices. The only downside for me, as I mentioned above, is they can get a little tiresome to wear for longer periods. A two hour movie isn't bad at all though. There might be some acceptable ultra lightweight headphones out there, I just didn't find any that would plug into my TV's optical.
Wow, thanks for the great info! It's just what I was looking for. The price on them is really decent too!
-
I'm currently using the Sony MDR-RF985RK. They also deliver great sound, but I don't get any interference with them.
I pulled the trigger on a set of those.
They are great for the price! Thanks for the recommendation Ben!
-
I pulled the trigger on a set of those.
They are great for the price! Thanks for the recommendation Ben!
No problemo!
-
I'm in my 20s and I've got the same problem - especially an issue with newer films. I just have TV speakers, no special sound system. I have to jack up the volume to hear what the hell people are saying, then comes the insanely loud gunshots and explosions, and I've got to drop volume again. Quite annoying, so many times I just stick with older movies and TV shows.
-
I think it's an old fart problem. My wife and I have no problem hearing the dialog on that show.
I have to partially retract that statement. Although we have no problem with dialog on Marvel's AOS, a lot of other shows do present that problem.
I just got a sound bar, which sounds really good. However, I wish I'd referred to Ben's post about his before I bought this one. Mine has no "News" setting and such. =(
-
What is this "television" of which you speak?
-
If I could just find a way to mute the laugh track on some of those sitcoms, they might be watchable. The Big Bang Theory, for example...
-
I wonder if its a problem of speaker settings (whether the mixing settings in the original material or in the user's equipment).
Maybe the audio channels for the broadcast / cablecast is mixed for a modern 5.1 system?
Maybe the audio settings on the TV are set for 5.1 system that isn't hooked up?
I notice on my Netflix streams that Netflix defaults to 5.1 audio, even though I only have built in TV speakers. Switching it to std stereo makes the audio much cleaner. I've seen this many time with my setup that mismatched settings or incoming signal will wash out the dialog and cause the music and background effects to overwhelm it.
Another vote for checkng your system's settings. Make sure the center channel is enabled. If it isn't, you'll get the exact problem you described... little or no dialog and tons of ambient/music/fill.
Also, if you have a cable box of some sort, make sure it's set properly for your TV setup (2 channel stereo for a TV-only system, 5.1 for a home theatre system, etc)
Brad