"The evils of tyranny are rarely seen but by him who resists it."
While it may stretch matters to call what is going on with regards the church "tyranny," John Hay's old quote does have a salient point.
Mr. Horner-Ibler seems to believe that the church should be paying for birth control despite the beliefs of Catholicism. Since he apparantly accepts that a priori and sees no reason to question it the rest simply flies right over his head. He winds up totally clueless.
I am not certain what his points about tax exemptions and whatnots has to do with the matter unless he simply believes that since the church apparantly "won" those they should simply "take a loss" on the matter of conscience and be silent about it.