Safeco is a normal insurance company, my Mom uses them.
They called back, finally. The estimate they have from their adjuster is $1471.70 based on a visual inspection of the car using a non-OEM fender. They did not allow for the mechanical damage and only allowed for the body work. We agreed that they will have it towed to a shop of my choice and we will reassess the estimate based on what the shop says.
I may not get OEM, the car is a 1999 Toyota Avalon so availability is a question.
I really don't want the rental car, I'm always hauling the dog around and as such take the truck.