Give it to me and I will make you a very nice ring out of it. Granted, I will keep any excess as payment for my time.
Actually, sell them on ebay. Pre 65 coins, dimes, quarters, etc., are going for roughly 25 times face value. Eagles can go for a lot higher than spot depending on rarity of the year and condition. 1oz bars are going for spot. The key to this is that you only pay ebay/paypal fees about 15%. This is more than a dealer will pay and Uncle Sam doesn't need to know.