I'm not a fan of slip ons, think they look dorky. =p
But the ones in the pic look nice. I'd say from your description, the ones in the pic probably look better.
At your vigorous, youthful age, MBS, I don't expect you to get the idea of "slip ons". "Slip ons" are not intended for "full of life" young teenagers and twenty-somethings, who have energy to spare (I think I recall you saying you're either a very late teenager or a very young twenty-something) tying shoes. Us middle aged people are fat and unvigorous, typically. We don't have extra energy to spare for tying shoes that don't really need to be tied.
Now, while I was picking out this particular pair of shoes at "the walmarts", Erica became amused and distracted by a pair of slippers that were obviously designed for elderly women. They were comfortable (looking, I didn't try them on), they were baby blue, they were fuzzy, and they had little bows on them... I told Erica, "those slippers are for peoplewho have utterly given up any shred of concern for what other wal-mart shoppers think of them". I'm 37 now. I figure ten more years and then I'll be wearing the male version of those slippers when I shop.