I've been thinking of buying one of these or another for over 6 months now. Each has something I want; neither has everything. I realize both are expensive, but with the down payment I've been saving for, they're within my budget.
The problem is, I can't think of any basis on which to make a decision. I don't have a family, so room isn't a real concern. They're both rated at about the same mileage, but the Subaru needs premium gas. The Dodge can tow up to 3800 lb., but I've towed something maybe three times in my entire life. They both have loads of power (Hemi in the Dodge, of course). The Dodge is cooler, but since when should "cool" be an issue? The recent Durango ball-joint recall (and the bad time my sister-in-law got trying to get hers fixed) has me worried about the Dodge.
So there it is - each has its pluses and minuses. This would be a daily driver. I have an F150 for the trips to the Home Despot.
Oh, and I realize I'll be taking a big hit on depreciation and all, but the choice is between these two - not between new and used.
What say you?