Ok, you had to know by reading the thread's title that this was going to be a silly, off-the-wall question. Working 3rd shift, sometimes these questions come out of nowhere and are promptly tossed around.
I recently saw the old 1980's movie The Final Countdown (staring Michael Douglas, Martin Sheen, Katharine Ross) on View it Now (Netflix) and after briefly mentioning this, somehow I became involved in an office discussion on the following scenario:
The USS Nimitiz of today is sucked into the same vortex that transported the Nimitiz of 1980 (from the movie) and for whatever reason, they faced off (perhaps one of the two carriers want to change history and the other plans to prevent it). I would think the more modern Nimitz would hold a distinct advantage as over 30 years has elapsed between the two.
A couple of my buddies believe that today's Nimitz might hold some advantage, but it wouldn't be a game changer due to the F-14 Tomcat and its armament typical of 1980 (could wreak havok on even the ships of today) flown by skilled pilots.
The Phoenix was brought up several times as being a threat to modern aircraft and the carrier itself.
Admittedly, most of what I know either comes from books I read when I was a kid or Wikipedia these days. Heck, the whole discussion brought up fond memories of the posters I used to have on my bedroom wall as a kid, especially one of an F-14 Tomcat, F-15 Eagle, F-16 Falcon and F-18 Hornet flying in formation.
Anyway, from what I could dig up on the Phoenix (or AIM-54 according to Wikipedia) is that its was a long range air-to-air missile. Honestly, wouldn't a 1980's AIM-54 be something we could counter with modern evasive maneuvers?
Bottom line: How do you think this would hash out if both sides were aware of each other and somehow also were aware of the date each arrived from ("they're more advanced than us"/"We're more advance than them")? I think the obvious advantage would be that the crew of the current Nimitz would be aware of what the armaments (and specifications thereof) of the other Nimitz but not the other way around.
But would this guarantee a rout?
I would think this shouldn't involve any nukes, just for the sake of arguement.
Yeah, we're now bored but the lively discussion has yet to be settled.
Oh, BTW... I am completely aware many of you have the song The Final Countdown by Europe going through your head now and that wasn't intended. We had to deal with that all night too, sorry.
Thanks in advance!