Manning is in the top five in virtually every category in which QBs are rated for the past season.
He's No. 1 in overall rating and in total TDs, No. 2 in yards, third in completions, completion percentage, and touch down percentage, 4th in total attempts, yards per attempt, and interception percentage, and fifth in interceptions.
There's only one category in which Brady cracked the top 5 -- touchdowns. In four of the offensive categories he was 10th or lower (completion percentage - 13th, yards per attempt 15th, TD percentage 10th, and interceptions 11th).
That's been a pretty consistent story for the past several years, as well, and really proves exactly what I said in my previous message -- Brady is a solid quarterback on a very solid, very deep team, but Manning is a spectacular quarterback who has the ability to carry his team on his numbers.