Most Big Box retail jacks are meh quality at best, even the "!Professional Grade!" units. You don't get past "Designed for Occasional Use and Considered Disposable" products until you get into brands like Hein-Werner, Omega Lift, Sunex, AF&F, etc.. Given your budget and a presumption it will be used infrequently, Harbor Freight is your friend. Just be sure to store it sitting on a pig mat and keep a quart of oil available to top off the hydraulics every so often.
Also, having a good set of jack stands should go without saying, but I'm saying it anyway.
Brad