As I think was mentioned, I am hearing Andor was good (as far as Star Wars goes), but I just can't see myself signing up for Disney again to watch it. I don't want to support that company. I figure there will be non-Disney options at some point.
I watched Andor. And I think Rogue One is the only good contribution that Disney has made to the Star Wars story and franchise.
But I have a big problem with Andor, that I am surprised others don't have: The whole reason Casian committed to the Scarrif raid was because of his time as a spy. He and his fellow wet-work mercs had been fighting for the rebellion their entire lives. They had done unconscionable things that they had a hard time living with (our introduction to Casian in that movie is evidence of this well enough, when he kills his informant contact because the man is incapable of escaping imperial arrest). They had invested their consciences and souls into the Rebellion, and it wasn't paying off. So they committed to the Scarrif raid under Jyn's leadership, in a bid to finally spark the real war for freedom rather than the endless political wrangling that Mon Mothma and Bail Organa were mired in.
I wanted to see THIS side of Casian Andor. The spy, the wet-work for the Rebellion, the selling of his soul to buy freedom for all. And I don't think this show presented that.