Who says I don't like the question?
As for "creepy," yeah, I think watching my country wink at a huge influx of people committing illegal trespass qualifies in spades. No one said all Mexicans, latinos, or "Hispanics" are intrinsically bad, but all illegal aliens are law-breakers and, in the opinion of most, are net minus for the society in the ways that count most. If you want to condone law-breaking and fiscal parasitism, THAT is creepy. Also "creepy" is ignoring gangs, street crime, identity theft, drunken driving, drain and strain on resources and infrastructure. Yeah, we can talk about "creepy" if you really want to.
How to get them to leave? Begin by cutting off employment and public benefits--penalizing employers, stopping welfare payments, barring "free" education, and abolishing "anchor babies"--then we'll see where we stand and what we do next.
I realize what you want me to say, and, to be honest, I think your sanctimony is more repulsive than any draconian methods I might propose. Sanctimony is going to kill America sure as hell.