Nice clean template Nick. Not bad for a Boilermaker
Clean and simple like the one Nick linked to are best. Your site is overloaded with graphics and cutesy stuff like
this on the homepage. It's okay to show RKBA folks as "everyday", but you still have to maintain a bit of decorum. Polite Society and all that. Otherwise, visitors won't take you seriously.
Think of it like a newspaper. The important stuff goes on the front page above the fold (near the top) and everything else is below that or on a separate page that is linked.
This should be right under your banner:
"SAFR is a Michigan firearms rights organization. We were founded on the idea that active involvement is the best way to protect our gun rights and through grass roots and working with other groups, we are making positive changes in Michigan. Please join us! "
Just my .02