Walking dead season 5 (Spoilers)

[K Frame]

"Can you afford to kill him in the post-apocalypse?"

Same thought crossed my mind, as well.

[Ned Hamford]

I thought that was a big reason behind the death of Noah; it removes an immediate and apparent need.  Gone is the guy that probably could have used a bit of surgery to improve his leg. 

[TommyGunn]

I see Rick has finally in Ricktator meltdown mode.  And Michonne took him out of the fray!  Atleast she didn't use her katana.

Things are looking to get more interesting next week.   

[Ben]

Looks like a few of them are on their way to cuckooland. I was kinda surprised that zombie-hardened Rick took that much of a licking from one of the soft people behind the wall. I was figuring it would be a one punch knockout.

There's potential for another group split for the season finale.

For a firearms nitpick: They have a whole freakin' armory in that place. Why in hell would Daryl's buddy checkout a snubby as his only firearm to go outside the wall? If I'm going out scavenging or whatever, I'm taking at least a rifle every damn time - for the deadly people if not for the walkers.

Also interesting that the coward pulled a Glock out of that coffee can.

[JN01]

For a firearms nitpick: They have a whole freakin' armory in that place. Why in hell would Daryl's buddy checkout a snubby as his only firearm to go outside the wall?

Also interesting that the coward pulled a Glock out of that coffee can.

He tried using an autoloading pistol, but kept limp wristing it.    I noticed that too. Five or six shots and a slow reload wouldn't be optimal when a herd of walkers pops up.

I wonder if Mr. Spineless intends to keep his secret safe by taking out Glen.

[Angel Eyes]

Looks like a few of them are on their way to cuckooland. I was kinda surprised that zombie-hardened Rick took that much of a licking from one of the soft people behind the wall. I was figuring it would be a one punch knockout.

Pete had more practice from beating on his wife.

There's potential for another group split for the season finale.

Yup, some folks are going to be exiled.

For a firearms nitpick: They have a whole freakin' armory in that place. Why in hell would Daryl's buddy checkout a snubby as his only firearm to go outside the wall? If I'm going out scavenging or whatever, I'm taking at least a rifle every damn time - for the deadly people if not for the walkers.

Because it matched his outfit?

Also interesting that the coward pulled a Glock out of that coffee can.

That's not the same Glock that Rick hid in the blender, is it?

[Jamisjockey]

Mean drunk fighting for his property.  He's bigger than rick by a solid 20 pounds too.

Season finale is going to be sporty.

[Ben]

That's not the same Glock that Rick hid in the blender, is it?

That's what I was wondering.

[MikeB]

That's not the same Glock that Rick hid in the blender, is it?

It was the same Glock. There was a big number or letter on the grip.

I also wondered why the one guy would have that snubnose, not the most accurate thing in the world at distance.

Of course suspension of disbelief, when it comes down to it a Katana nor a crossbow are really all that practical either.

[K Frame]

A katana is monumentally practical in a zombie apocalypse, especially when they're drawn by sound...

[T.O.M.]

A katana is monumentally practical in a zombie apocalypse, especially when they're drawn by sound...

Isn't that why we're all putting swords in our SHTF kits?   

[K Frame]

Isn't that why we're all putting swords in our SHTF kits?   

Mine goes on top of my tactical wheelbarrow.

[TechMan]

Mine goes on top of my tactical wheelbarrow.

Right along with the additional trauma plates.

[TommyGunn]

Isn't that why we're all putting swords in our SHTF kits?  

Chris, firearms are really nice in a SHTF situation.  in a Zombie Apocalypse, however (and mind you I am here taking the premise of the TV series literally) one might, at some point, just not be able to get to the local Sam's Sporting Goods and replenish one's supply of 5.56mm, .22RF, .30-30, .25ACP, 9mm., .45ACP, 600 Nitro Express, or <insert favorite caliber here>.
A Katana, sword, kukri, pike,  broadsword and similar weapon might be a really good idea as you don't need to "feed" them for them to work.   Inconvenient as they only work close up, true, but there is likely a time that will come when one may really appreciate having such a weapon in one's remora.

[MikeB]

Chris, firearms are really nice in a SHTF situation.  in a Zombie Apocalypse, however (and mind you I am here taking the premise of the TV series literally) one might, at some point, just not be able to get to the local Sam's Sporting Goods and replenish one's supply of 5.56mm, .22RF, .30-30, .25ACP, 9mm., .45ACP, 600 Nitro Express, or <insert favorite caliber here>.
A Katana, sword, kukri, pike,  broadsword and similar weapon might be a really good idea as you don't need to "feed" them for them to work.   Inconvenient as they only work close up, true, but there is likely a time that will come when one may really appreciate having such a weapon in one's remora.

Something like a Katana requires a pretty specialized skill set to use effectively. Realistically as well I don't se one lasting the constant cutting through bone and skulls the way she does. I also think the decapitated heads would eventually lead to an unfortunate incident of someone getting bit by a flying head. Hence the need for suspension of disbelief.

[T.O.M.]

Chris, firearms are really nice in a SHTF situation.  in a Zombie Apocalypse, however (and mind you I am here taking the premise of the TV series literally) one might, at some point, just not be able to get to the local Sam's Sporting Goods and replenish one's supply of 5.56mm, .22RF, .30-30, .25ACP, 9mm., .45ACP, 600 Nitro Express, or <insert favorite caliber here>.
A Katana, sword, kukri, pike,  broadsword and similar weapon might be a really good idea as you don't need to "feed" them for them to work.   Inconvenient as they only work close up, true, but there is likely a time that will come when one may really appreciate having such a weapon in one's remora.

You are very much correct.  In the Walking Dead world, I would indeed want a silent weapon that was not dependent on ammo supplies.  A sword might be a really good choice.  I was joking about adding one to my TV kit.  I already have one.   

I do have a sword.  Not in my kit, though.

[Blakenzy]

I'm surprised they never developed any sort of light soft armor to counter the zombie bites... Thick canvas would do just fine, leather even better. I mean c'mon.. their SOP is grappling with zombies and stabbing them in the head? And the is no mention of having to wash up afterwards or clean their tools...  Really, that's the messiest, riskiest approach you can take, zombie goo all over, getting into any scratches you might have.

Also, when only head shots count and "quiet" just might keep you out of a horde, a suppressed .22LR would be a very desirable weapon to have. Have not seen ANY of those. Not one.. NOT ONE!!!  . Picture Ruger 10/22 Charger with 25 round mag and integral suppressor.

I enjoy the series but some things make me go 

[TommyGunn]

Something like a Katana requires a pretty specialized skill set to use effectively. Realistically as well I don't se one lasting the constant cutting through bone and skulls the way she does. I also think the decapitated heads would eventually lead to an unfortunate incident of someone getting bit by a flying head. Hence the need for suspension of disbelief.

OK, maybe not a katana per se, but a sword or pike .... something you don't have to "feed."

I'm surprised they never developed any sort of light soft armor to counter the zombie bites... Thick canvas would do just fine, leather even better. I mean c'mon.. their SOP is grappling with zombies and stabbing them in the head? And the is no mention of having to wash up afterwards or clean their tools...  Really, that's the messiest, riskiest approach you can take, zombie goo all over, getting into any scratches you might have.

Also, when only head shots count and "quiet" just might keep you out of a horde, a suppressed .22LR would be a very desirable weapon to have. Have not seen ANY of those. Not one.. NOT ONE!!!  . Picture Ruger 10/22 Charger with 25 round mag and integral suppressor.

I enjoy the series but some things make me go 

Another good idea.   It might make one awfully sweaty in the Georgia summer ...but atleast one has protection.

They do have suppresssed weapons but IIRC, no .22s   Maybe 22 is as rare in their world as it is in ours ....

[MikeB]

Realistically suppressing a .22lr is a bit hit or miss if you want it it reliably function in a semi-auto. Most .22lr tends to break the sound barrier, especially through longer barrels. A susbsonic 9mm load or .45ACP is a bit more reliable. 9mm that is subsonic requires a 147+ grain bullet with most commercial loads and is somewhat uncommon on store shelves, never mind random finds in the ZA. 45ACP is mostly subsonic by default.

This brings up another issue I have with the last episode, was it Sasha shooting from the tower and then in the woods with what was probably a .223 AR that was making the movie silencer sound."? A .223 is loud through a suppressor in reality, you can kind of get away without ears; but there is no doubt at all people (zombies) would know someone was shooting (making loud noises).

I own suppressors in all of the calibeers listed above, so once again when watching the show suspension of disbelief, but I sometimes still cringe at the non-reality.

[Angel Eyes]

Right along with the additional trauma plates.

I thought those were duct-taped to his back.

[Fitz]

I'm surprised they never developed any sort of light soft armor to counter the zombie bites... Thick canvas would do just fine, leather even better.

Glenn and others wore some armor at the prison, but yeah you'd think they'd try to improvise something for everyone

[K Frame]

"Something like a Katana requires a pretty specialized skill set to use effectively."

Realistically, no more so than any other cutting weapon in such a situation, and it's something that's going to be learned pretty quickly. You're not going up against samurai walkers... just run of the mill southern walkers.

And, any bladed weapon is going to get nicked and dull chopping through bones and such. That's addressed with maintenance.

But remember, it's pretty evident from the way they stick a knife through a skull and the like, that once you turn into a zombie, your bones turn into marshmallow fluff.

[K Frame]

"I'm surprised they never developed any sort of light soft armor to counter the zombie bites... Thick canvas would do just fine, leather even better."

Even a jeans jacket and canvas work gloves would provide a lot of protection. A couple of seasons ago on Talking Dead they had a guy giving tips on how to survive the apocalypse, and one of the tricks he showed was using duct tape to armor a hoodie. Wouldn't last forever, especially in hot weather, but inexpensive.

[K Frame]

If I were in a zombie situation, the first place I'd head (if I were still in the DC metro area) would be either the American History museum or the Freer Art Gallery at the Smithsonian. Their holdings include dozens, if not hundreds, of authentic Japanese katanas.

If I were in Pennsylvania, I'd head either to the Pennsylvania State Museum in Harrisburg or the Pennsylvania Military Museum in Boalsburg for the same reason. When I worked in the PA museum system in the 1980s they had dozens of katanas (most of them still incredibly sharp) that were captured by US troops during WW II. Even a run of the mill Imperial Japanese military katana is going to be tons better than one of the pieces of crap that you get from a place like US Cavalry here in the US.

A Nepalese kukri wouldn't be a bad choice, either.

[erictank]

"Something like a Katana requires a pretty specialized skill set to use effectively."

Realistically, no more so than any other cutting weapon in such a situation, and it's something that's going to be learned pretty quickly. You're not going up against samurai walkers... just run of the mill southern walkers.

And, any bladed weapon is going to get nicked and dull chopping through bones and such. That's addressed with maintenance.

But remember, it's pretty evident from the way they stick a knife through a skull and the like, that once you turn into a zombie, your bones turn into marshmallow fluff.

After 2-3 years of decomposing? Yeah, they probably are going to be softer than when the owners were living.