%50-60 of the questions were "So Candidate X, Candidate Y said you were stupid and called your wife a whore. Please respond."
%10 were nonsensical fluff.
The rest were decent. One Second Amendment question, they talked about it for like 10 seconds apiece and Cruz got cut off by that loathesome eunuch Jake Tapper.
As for the candidates...
Trump has no substantiative plans, and doesn't do his flippant insult play to the crowd thing well in a small space without a friendly audience. He's super "weird uncle Chester" creepy whenever he talks about women, and he thinks vaccines cause autism. He's right about politicians being bought and paid for whores and needing to shut the border down. One of his supporters on the radio this morning perfectly sums up both why people like him and why so many are confused about his support. Paraphrased, it was "He really hates politicians like I do, and I don't care about anything else."
Carson is brilliant. He also whispers, mumbles, and seems incredibly hesitant. Very cautious, which I like in a brain surgeon a lot more than I do in a President. He also has some bizarre policy stands, like calling for a two tiered minimum wage that's indexed to... something.
Carly Fiorina had a lot of good lines, and was generally regarded as "winning" the debate. Quick on her feet, the most passionately emotional on the Planned Parenthood videos (voice was trembling with anger). Mild bitchy resting face, and came out strong as a drug warrior with an anecdote about her kid ODing on pot needles or something. Talked a lot about Iran, and took advantage of Tapper the Eunuch's reluctance to interrupt her by just ignoring him which I loved.
The sack of lard from NJ had some solid lines, and wouldn't stop dancing on the grave of the 9/11 dead to advance his career. Vile and disgusting man.
Huckabee did really well, which is unfortunate as I dislike the man. Came across as the level headed elder statesman focussed on attacking Hillary not his fellow R's. He even had a really measured and totally reasonable answer to Kim Davis which surprised me. If I didn't know his record I'd like him a lot right now.
Cruz is very smart and has good arguments. His delivery sucks and he comes across as unlikable as a person. Tapper constantly cut him off short, it was obvious the moderator hates him. I think he'd do well as a President, don't know how well he'd do getting elected.
Rubio did well, fiery and passionate without descending into name calling and squabbling. If he wasn't a favor de la amnistÃa he'd be more interesting. Loves him some foreign intervention.
Jeb! Bush is like a fatter Mitt Romney. He got as upset about Trump calling out his brother's screwups as Fiorina got about abortion. Pathetic establishment turd. I tried to ignore him. Oh, and he smoked the devil weed back in the day which leads us to...
Rand Paul didn't get to talk much, made some excellent points, came across as not very likable. I think he also got into a slap fight with Trump at one point but I missed it. Lack of face time, lack of debate impact. Called Jeb a hypocrite who used his wealth power and privilege to avoid punishment for his drug use in a way that poor people esp blacks and hispanics could not. I thought it was an excellent point, but given some of the stupider elements of the R base I think being pro-pot and mentioning minorities in a positive light might hurt him.
Walker had even less screen time than Rand and suffered similarly for it. Seems like a competent dude, and his stuff on not backing down from union thugs threatening his family's life was excellent.
Oh, and Gary Shandling was up there doing a John McCain impression skit which seemed weird.