If your former Scoutmaster was the District Chairman and allowed this to happen, then shame on him. It's his job to run the District and the District Advancement committee. They sign off on projects and BoR. He wasn't doing his job of reviewing and providing oversight. Shame on him.
And Eagle Scout is not "Checkbox". Yes, some of the lower requirements are. But once you get to Star, it's not about learning Scout Skills, it's about developing Leadership. You can't tell me that any, but the rarest of the rare 14 yo has learned those skills.
If that what that Scoutmaster and that unit were doing, (and the Old Comanche Trails District were allowing) then they need to be reported to Texas Trails Council, Southern Region, and/or National in Dallas. Otherwise Eagle at 14 IS a Participation Trophy.