When I bought my current Forester in 2020 it came with only one key. Have NO clue how a retired couple, who only put 32,000 miles on it in a little under 5 years, managed to lose the valet key, the other fob key, and the master information.
When I bought my 2012 Forester in 2015 I got all of that stuff.
I figured I'd like to have a back up key, so I checked with the dealer... $250
So, I checked with a local locksmith chain that promises to "SAVE YOU LOTS OVER THE DEALER PRICE FOR NEW KEYS!"
They wanted $230, and programming was extra. Wow. BIG savings...
I still only have the one key. I really should get another one.
As for these keys being too big to comfortably carry in your pocket... yeah, they're annoying.
So annoying, in fact, that I quit carrying my car and house keys in my pocket. I have them on a lanyard that I wear around my neck.