Try the RDB. It's tough as can be, made out of old truck tarps. Smells a little funny (like old truck tarps!) when you get it, but the odor's gone quick, especially after you get caught in the rain in it. Had mine in the ocean, ripped at by my dog and run over by my wife's car. The thing gets better the more beat up it gets.
I've had mine for about a year. Had a Tilley from years ago, but have to admit, it made me feel like an older dude at Disney, and I'm not ready for that, yet! With the Real Deal hat, I sometimes I think I may not actually be cool enough to wear it. Their site's kind of fun, realdealbrazil.com.